An Analysis of Louis Vuitton Tote Bags vs Goyard Tote Bags: Unveiling the Manufacturing Truth Behind Their Luxury Appeal

In the world of high-end luxury brands, Louis Vuitton and Goyard are two of the most revered names. Each represents a distinct heritage of luxury and craftsmanship, and in the realm of handbags, the Onthego and St. Louis GM are both iconic and highly regarded models. This article will compare these two handbags from both the manufacturer’s and the consumer’s perspectives, revealing the refined craftsmanship and unique appeal behind each.

I.  From the Manufacturer's Perspective

An amateur looks at style, a connoisseur looks at craftsmanship. The secret to a tote bag’s pricing lies partly in its brand book, and partly in its cuts, stitches, and hardware. Today, setting aside marketing narratives and speaking from a bag manufacturer’s perspective, this article will dissect the “inner structure” of two popular tote bags—revealing whether the high markup stems from tangible craft dividends or mere brand magic

Chapter 1: Cut Components 

1.Louis Vuitton Tote Bag - Onthego MM

Cut Components：

Monogram canvas must be "mirror-matched"​ during cutting, strictly adhering to the pattern alignment principle. The patterns on the front and back of the bag body must be completely symmetrical, especially ensuring the continuity of the pattern at the connection points between the handles and the body. This results in a 35% increase in fabric wastage. Additionally, the handle sections require "pre-forming treatment", where they are pressed and shaped in molds for 48 hours.

The handle pattern is symmetrical one by one

Lining System :

• 5-layer composite structure: waterproof coating + canvas base + support mesh + microfiber lining + leather edging
• The lining alone requires 14 independent cut pieces, with each edge undergoing piping treatment.
• The bottom utilizes a "boat-shaped base"​ one-piece cut design, increasing load-bearing capacity by 200%.

One-piece boat-shaped sole cutting

Material utilization rate: 45%

2.Goyard Tote Bag - St. Louis GM

Cut Components：

The classic Chevron pattern requires a 45-degree bias cut, with each piece's cutting angle error under 0.5 degrees, resulting in an astonishing 65% fabric wastage. Mirror-matching of patterns is required at bag connection points, increasing production time by 40%

Mirror facing flower at the connection of the bag body

Number of Cut Components and Structure:

Each bag body consists of 27–32 individual cut pieces, which is 50% more than what meets the eye. A hidden reinforcement gusset is used at the handle-to-body connection points, invisible externally yet doubling the load-bearing capacity. Coated canvas must undergo constant temperature and humidity conditioning (temperature: 22°C ±1, humidity: 55% ±3) before cutting.

Material Utilization Rate: 35% (the lowest in the industry, yet achieves a distinctive texture)

Chapter 2:  Machine Stitching Technique

1.Louis Vuitton Onthego

Stitching Craftsmanship Standards:

Uses specially-made M40 polyester thread with a melting point as high as 260°C. A five-step reinforcement method is adopted during stitching: backstitch at start → straight stitch → backstitch at end → adhesive fixation → heat-sealed edge finishing. Stitch length: 2.8mm, tolerance ±0.1mm. The distance from edge stitching to the edge is strictly maintained at 3.5mm.

Special M40 Polyester Thread

Labor Cost: 180 minutes per piece (including manual pattern alignment and positioning)

2.Goyard St. Louis 

Stitching Craftsmanship Standards:

Fully handcrafted using the "saddle stitching with double needles" technique, with a stitch density of 7–8 stitches per inch. The stitching angle is strictly maintained at 30°. Triple backstitching is applied at key stress points, ensuring the thread lifespan exceeds 50 years. Each artisan produces only 1.5 pieces per day. Waxed linen thread is used, costing **22 times** more per meter than standard polyester thread.

Waxed Linen Thread

Labor Cost: 240 minutes per piece (fully hand-sewn)

Chapter 3:  Hardware

1. Louis Vuitton  Onthego

Hardware Craftsmanship Standards:

Locks are made using zinc alloy die-casting + palladium plating. Palladium, a precious metal rarer than silver, offers excellent corrosion resistance and stability, with a corrosion resistance rating of Class A. Zipper pulls feature custom versions of riri or YKK, with pull tab weight precision down to the gram and engraved brand initials, with a tolerance of <0.2mm. All hardware undergoes a 48-hour salt spray test. Inside the bag, a leather label is hot-stamped with a "production batch code" for each item, consisting of 6 characters (2 letters + 4 digits). Strap clasps are tested for 3,000 open-close cycles.

Cost Proportion: 9.5%

2.Goyard St. Louis 

Hardware Craftsmanship Standards:

Employs a rare palladium finish, which is 30% lighter than standard hardware, specifically optimized for travel needs. The iconic "Goyardine" pattern is engraved or cast onto the hardware pieces, finished with a three-layer electroplating process

Cost Proportion: 7.5%

Manufacturing-Side Comprehensive Data Comparison

From the production line perspective, the fundamental differences among these two tote bags lie not in the level of brand markup but in the two distinct manufacturing philosophies they represent.

• Louis Vuitton is a masterpiece of precision industry—the pattern-matching cuts and five-step stitching method are essentially about achieving top-tier quality control through extreme standardization. Its cost is primarily invested in ensuring that every bag meets industrial perfection down to the last millimeter.
• Goyard represents the stubborn craft of artisans—with 65% fabric wastage and two hours of fully hand-stitched work, it is almost a form of performance art in today’s era of digital production. Its high price stems from its deliberate refusal of any efficiency optimization, preserving pre-industrial production methods in their entirety.

As a manufacturer, we do not judge which philosophy is superior, but we are fully aware of the cost behind each choice. The price paid by consumers is, in fact, a payment for the path the brand has chosen—whether it is paying for the perfection of industrialization, or paying for the traditional craftsmanship that stays true to its origins.

II. The Consumer Perspective

Chapter 1 : Brand Background and Positioning

• Louis Vuitton Onthego is a tote bag line introduced by Louis Vuitton in 2019. Its design is inspired by the brand’s iconic Sac Plat handbag. The Onthego is known for its oversized capacity, clean and straightforward interior structure, and the bold Monogram Giant canvas. Accented with Monogram Reverse details along the sides and handles, the bag quickly gained global popularity upon its release.
• Goyard St. Louis is a classic tote bag from the historic French brand Goyard, founded in 1853—earlier than Louis Vuitton’s emergence on the Parisian luxury luggage scene. First introduced in the 1930s, the St. Louis tote has become a symbol of the brand. It is highly regarded for its signature Goyardine printed canvas, as well as its lightweight yet durable construction.

Chapter 2: Size and Capacity Comparison

Louis Vuitton Onthego is available in three size options:

PM (Small): 25 × 19 × 11 cm, ideal for petite users for everyday commuting.

Capacity: Fits a smartphone, a Sarah long wallet, keys, lipstick, tissues, and a small notebook.

Weight: Approximately 700 g

MM (Medium):  35 × 27 × 14 cm, the most popular size, suitable for daily commuting and short trips.

Capacity:  Fits a 13-inch laptop, smartphone, keys, a Zippy wallet, and earphones.

Weight:  Approximately 900 g

GM (Large):  41 × 34 × 19 cm, suitable for users around 170 cm in height.

Capacity: Fits a 13-inch laptop, smartphone, a Sarah long wallet, keys, lipstick, and tissues.

Weight: Approximately 1,200 g

Goyard St. Louis is available in two sizes:

PM: 34 × 15 × 28 cm

Capacity: Fits a 13-inch laptop, smartphone, keys, a Zippy wallet, and earphones.

Weight: Approximately 280 g

GM: 40 × 20 × 32 cm

Capacity: Fits a 13-inch laptop, smartphone, a Sarah long wallet, keys, lipstick, and tissues.

Weight: Approximately 370 g

Chapter 3:  Cleaning and Maintenance Comparison

1. Comparison of Material Properties

• Louis Vuitton Onthego is made of Monogram coated canvas combined with natural vegetable-tanned leather trim. The Monogram canvas is a composite of PVC film and pure cotton canvas, featuring a 0.03 mm micro-textured surface that offers both durability and water resistance. The vegetable-tanned leather handles are treated with natural plant-based tannins and will naturally oxidize over time, gradually changing from a light almond color to a rich honey tone, creating a unique patina that reflects the passage of time.
• Goyard St. Louis GM is crafted from Goyardine canvas (a blend of hemp and cotton) with leather trim. The Goyardine canvas is extremely lightweight (approximately 350–400 g) and provides excellent water and scratch resistance. However, its surface coating is relatively thin, so prolonged exposure to direct sunlight should be avoided.    

2 .Comparison of Daily Cleaning Methods

3. Key Maintenance Guidelines Comparison

Louis Vuitton Onthego – Core Maintenance Principles:

• Protect from direct sunlight: Avoid prolonged exposure to sunlight to prevent the Monogram coated canvas from aging or fading.
• Keep away from moisture: Vegetable-tanned leather is prone to permanent water stains and must be kept completely dry.
• Regular leather care: Apply lanolin (ideally containing 15% wool fat) to the vegetable-tanned leather handles weekly to form a protective oxidized layer.
• Proper storage: Hang the bag in a dust bag and avoid folding to prevent “memory creases.”

Goyard St. Louis GM – Core Maintenance Principles:

• Lightweight care: Due to its light weight, daily maintenance only requires wiping with a soft cloth.
• Moisture and mold prevention: Keep the canvas dry and store in a moisture-free environment.
• Avoid compression: The bag’s structure is soft, so stuff it with filling to maintain its shape during storage.
• Regular ventilation: Air out the bag for about 2 hours each month to prevent coating degradation.

4. Purchase and Maintenance Cost Comparison

Louis Vuitton Onthego:

Retail Price : Onthego PM: $2,000 – $2,500

Onthego MM: $2,700 – $3,500

Onthego GM: $3,000 – $4,000

Basic Cleaning: ¥300–500

Deep Cleaning for Vegetable-Tanned Leather: Starting from ¥800

Hardware Replacement: Zipper pull: ¥800; lock repair: ¥1,200

Handle Replacement: Starting from ¥2,500

Goyard St. Louis:

Retail Price : St. Louis PM: ~$1,710 – $1,950

St. Louis GM: ~$1,890 – $2,500

• Basic Cleaning: $28–56

• Canvas Material Repair: $69–111

Hardware Maintenance: Relatively simple, with lower cost

Chapter 3：Overall Recommendations

Louis Vuitton Onthego is more suitable for:

• Users who prioritize fashion and brand recognition, making it perfect for commuting, travel, business meetings, and other diverse occasions.
• Those looking for classic, timeless value and are willing to invest in higher maintenance costs.
• Individuals who are comfortable with the natural color-changing process of vegetable-tanned leather.
• Users with high daily usage frequency, requiring durability.

Goyard St. Louis GM is more suitable for:

• Consumers who seek lightweight practicality and understated luxury. With its super-lightweight design and ample capacity, the print exudes a relaxed French vibe, making it ideal for daily commuting, short trips, gym visits, shopping, and more.
• Those prioritizing ease of use and lower maintenance costs
• Regular commuters who need to clean their bag frequently
• People who prefer a minimalist style and don’t seek extensive upkeep

Conclusion

A tote and carry bag is the complex product of brand heritage, marketing investments, channel costs, and the manufacturing costs described above. We admire the unwavering commitment to craftsmanship in cutting, stitching, and hardware, just as we respect the commercial wisdom of optimizing production processes to make good design more accessible. Every penny consumers spend, when viewed through this analytical lens, finds a tangible destination. Next time you pick up a tote bag, take a moment to examine the logic of its cut pieces, count the density of its stitches, and feel the substantial weight of its hardware—these unlying details will quietly tell you exactly what you’ve paid for.

	Author